by Shelly Leachman, UC Santa Barbara
A community of tiny stream bugs has proved that efforts to restore streams heavily polluted by an old Sierra Nevada mine are working.
Leviathan, Aspen and Bryant Creeks, once crystalline natural streams, have at times run a sickening and toxic rusty-orange color. The culprits: iron and other acidic, heavy metal pollutants released from the so-called Leviathan Mine, a badly scarred 250-acre open pit sulfur extraction site located about 25 miles southeast of Lake Tahoe.
But now, several miles of polluted stream are recovering and toxic flows are being abated, thanks to a collaboration led by a team of UC Santa Barbara scientists. Years of compiled research on the Leviathan project has been published in the Journal of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry.
Restoring a superfund site
“This is an encouraging story that shows the success of lasting efforts to capture and treat the mine effluent and improve stream water quality and ecological health,” said David Herbst, a UC Santa Barbara freshwater aquatic scientist who oversaw the group working for government regulators and industry representatives. “At the same time it also is cautionary in that there is still work to be done to complete the restoration.”
First established by Anaconda Mining in 1951, the sulfur extracted from Leviathan was trucked to another mining facility near Yerington, Nevada, where it was used to dissolve copper ore. In 1962, Anaconda ceased operations and sold the property to local interests. In 1977 Anaconda was purchased by Atlantic Richfield, later becoming a subsidiary of British Petroleum. Today BP remains actively involved in the cleanup effort at Leviathan, a “superfund” site as designated by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
An environmentally unfriendly practice
While open-pit or strip mining continues in the U.S. and around the world, it is widely regarded by scientists, naturalists and regulators as a dangerous environmental practice, posing a significant threat to the environment as such operations contaminate above-ground waterways and underground aquifers. The first step in abating the pollution, Herbst said, was through a process of containment.
Most of the snowmelt and rainfall draining off the exposed soils of the mine was captured in large ponds built at the lower end of the pit. The ponds hold back polluted water and prevent it from entering the streams. Chemical reaction tanks then treat the water in stages. Calcium oxide neutralizes the pH. This precipitates metals dissolved in the water back into solid form. The cleansed water is released into Leviathan Creek, while the sludge is left to settle in evaporation ponds. Trucks transport the dried sediment to hazardous waste storage sites.
An alternative treatment system on Aspen Creek uses sulfate-reducing bacteria to reverse the chemical process that first formed the acidic soup of metals. Here, the minerals settle in a microbial wetland while the biologically cleansed water flows back into the stream.
But the question for the project team was: How can we be sure that the newly reclaimed creek water will safely support and help restore life?
That’s when Herbst’s little bug friends took center stage.
Aquatic invertebrates as sentinel species
Herbst, who has dedicated much of his career to studying freshwater insect life, monitored the return of many insect species — including midges, mayflies, stoneflies and caddisflies — in downstream areas of the creek system. He discovered that they began to flourish after efforts to clean mine runoff, moving upstream as they recovered. As the water quality has improved, and the food web becomes reestablished, fish and other aquatic and riparian life can recover.
“The monitoring of stream bugs then tells us, by their numbers and variety, how well the treatments have worked to alleviate the toxicity,” said Herbst, who has studied the ecology of mountain streams for some 20 years from his laboratory at the Sierra Nevada Aquatic Research Laboratory, which is part of the UC Natural Reserve System. “Clearly, this is a case of the ‘canary in the coal mine’ and I’m glad to report that our canaries are alive and doing well.”
Altogether, Herbst said, the work shows that efforts to clean the water and restore life have been successful along downstream portions whereas upstream areas closer to the mine, while improved, remain in a damaged state. But because the mine location and altitude make it subject to heavy and inaccessible snows each winter, the toxic remediation efforts cannot be implemented 12 months a year.
“Complete recovery may require that cleanup efforts of chronic pollution continue year-round rather than only for the part of the year when the remote site can be accessed,” Herbst said.
The positive impact of science
Herbst called the project a resounding success. He credits his University of California colleagues, the U.S. EPA, and other community and industry stakeholders. Because of these efforts, Herbst says, some eight miles of polluted stream are recovering and toxic flows are no longer reaching the main stem of the East Carson River.
“One of the most important lessons from this work is that we cannot retreat from basic science,” Herbst said. “How it has been used in this case demonstrates the importance of using science to inform how we go about doing environmental cleanups and large-scale restoration projects. We must know what works and what doesn’t and under what circumstances, so we can be most successful and prudent in how we spend funds to restore damaged ecosystems.”